June 12, 2022

Not bad but not the best Kindaichi

After a strong start and solid middle, the ending was a letdown for me. It felt overly simplistic and the last 25 pages were almost a chore to read. I considered between giving 3 or 4 stars - it's really just the last 20-30 pages out of over 300 that disappointed me, but the impact was still enough to make me lean towards 3.

The setting and set up, as I've come to expect from Yokomizo, were superb. (In fact, if it wasn't for the fact that I have high expectations for his novels, I might have given 4 stars.) I'd still recommend this book to someone who liked his other works, but it doesn't come close to i.e. 獄門島.

Language: It felt simpler than 獄門島 and possibly even 本陣殺人事件, though it might just be that I've gotten pretty used to his writing style by now. I think there were fewer period specific words used.

Gradings:24
0
favorite_border
Relevant gradings from other volumes
help_outline
Belerith graded
on November 7, 2024
Belerith graded
on November 7, 2024
八つ墓村L38similar in difficulty toのぼうの城 上L39
Belerith graded
on July 22, 2023
八つ墓村L38harder than64 上L39
Belerith graded
on July 1, 2023
Belerith graded
on April 23, 2023
八つ墓村L38similar in difficulty to半落ちL38
Belerith graded
on October 13, 2022
八つ墓村L38similar in difficulty to道化の華L39
Belerith graded
on October 11, 2022
八つ墓村L38harder thanア、秋L37
Belerith graded
on August 2, 2022
Belerith graded
on August 2, 2022
Belerith graded
on August 2, 2022
Belerith graded
on August 2, 2022
Belerith graded
on August 2, 2022
本陣殺人事件L38similar in difficulty to殺人鬼L39
Belerith graded
on May 15, 2022
Belerith graded
on May 15, 2022
Belerith graded
on May 15, 2022
獄門島L38harder thanキッチンL30
Belerith graded
on May 15, 2022
本陣殺人事件L38harder than夜市L31
Belerith graded
on April 14, 2022
Belerith graded
on April 14, 2022
Belerith graded
on April 14, 2022
獄門島L38harder than乳と卵L37
Belerith graded
on April 14, 2022
獄門島L38harder than人間失格L39
Belerith graded
on April 14, 2022
Belerith graded
on April 14, 2022
Belerith graded
on April 14, 2022
Belerith graded
on April 14, 2022
獄門島L38harder than猫の事件L30