April 6, 2025

3 stories of strife - and the first(?) modern yuri manga

The manga contains 3 different stories of strife, with their accompanying angst and すれ違い. I believe all 3 stories are set in France (at the very least, the first one is). Overall they're a little hard to read, due to the small font size, and sometimes crowded paneling, but I think the stories are great - and it's worth reading for the historical value. The art seems to be a bit rougher and simpler than ゲッシング・ゲーム | L29, by the same author (2 years later iirc), but (especially in the titular story) can be really beautiful, creative, and evocative. I definitely would have preferred to read it at magazine size though! The language is fairly close to modern Japanese, with a few archaisms. If you've read things like マリア様がみてる, おにいさまへ, or さくら並木, this should be pretty easy.

白い部屋のふたり: Considered by some to be the first modern yuri manga, it's set in a cloistered, all-girls school, and the two MCs live in a distant room of the dormitory. The main tension in the story has to do with realizing romantic feelings, and the taboo of being a lesbian (both in an all-girls school, and in the world more broadly). It's easy to see where this solidified various tropes in modern yuri works. Similar to おにいさまへ, It can require a bit more interpretation to follow than more recent manga, but the emotional experience is definitely well-conveyed.

遠い讃美歌: A story of sibling (non-romantic) love - a troubled, but protective older brother, at odds with his family - and a deaf younger sister, who's been sheltered by her family, but really looks up to him. The communication issues and behaviors in this all felt very realistic, and I liked how developed and multilayered the characters and tensions were.

水の中の空: The story of a young girl who struggles to fit in with her new mother & siblings (from her father's remarriage). This one is the shortest and simplest of the 3 stories, and has a slight supernatural element.

Gradings:10
0
favorite_border
on March 11, 2025
on March 11, 2025
similar in difficulty to少女たちの痕にくちづけを 1L21
on March 11, 2025
on March 11, 2025
similar in difficulty toこの恋を星には願わない 1L22
on March 11, 2025
on March 11, 2025
easier thanIDOL×IDOL STORY! 1L23
on March 11, 2025
on March 11, 2025
similar in difficulty toGIRL FRIENDS 1L23