As an Amazon Associate, Natively earns from qualifying purchases through any Amazon links on the site.
All of our Movie & TV metadata comes from the wonderful project,
The Movie Database. Thank you! While we are permitted to use the TMDB API, we have not been endorsed or certified by TMDB.
This is a review of volumes 1-4 which are currently available, I assume there will be one more volume before the end.
I first started 変な家 with the novel but seeing how it was written more like a play and the frequent (more so than the 変な絵) intersections with the same image over and over, I decided the manga might be a good option. The sections I can directly compare are slim but I think this is a very good adaptation. It's very faithful, a lot of lines being straight up from the novel. But also some stuff inserted to set the scene more. Most of this story is sitting and talking, which in the hands of a less talented artist would make for a stale manga. But the artist here manages to make it feel much more dynamic and atmospheric. I also enjoy the way the main character is depicted. Although she doesn't have a strong personality, the designs androgyny (I read her as female, because the way her face is drawn doesn't look like any of the male characters in the manga, but I think it was vague on purpose, probably because it is not specified in the novel?) and fashion choices as well as the ever present bags under her eyes, add a lot of character. And, the artist simply is really good at their job at a technical level, the illustrations are beautiful throughout.
The story requires a bit of suspension of disbelief. The whole story is a bit silly and outrageous, but more so than that the characters reach those silly and outrageous conclusions far too quickly when there are often much more mundane possibilities. The by far worst instance of it happens very early on, so you'll know quickly if you can deal with it or not. For me, while I was mildly bothered by that I was entertained enough to not mind. I really enjoyed the aspect of theorizing only with the floor plan. Halfway through the series though, the direction changes a bit. For me, I enjoyed it somewhat less after this, as it felt more generic. But it is still not bad, and I imagine some people might prefer it.
Difficulty wise I found it pretty breezy, besides a section in volume 4 which had a lot of unfamiliar vocab.