April 7, 2025

Simply and consistently charming

This is the original Hanako Muraoka translation of LM Montgomery's Anne of Green Gables, abridged and fully furigana-ed for younger readers (the unabridged version is here). According to the afterward, no story content was cut and most of the edits were minor -- to modernize vocabulary or reword sentences to be clearer -- but I don't own the original to confirm the extent of the changes.

Difficulty- and learning-wise, I found it to be pretty challenging, but in a way that felt valuable. The book is replete with antiquated language, even after being abridged; なさる everywhere, lots of things like 悪うございます and 言いなすった, and more than a few words that aren't in J-E dictionaries. The average sentence length is also quite long, with lots of relative clauses that can sometimes get painful to keep straight. Because of its age and how specific a lot of the vocabulary is, I'm not sure how broadly applicable the knowledge is that I got from this book (which is why I deducted a star for learning), but I did learn a great amount and felt motivated to dig into the things I didn't understand throughout.

Story-wise, this is a classic work and well-loved for a reason. Somehow I never read it in English and had no knowledge of the story outside of "red-headed orphan gets adopted in rural Prince Edward Island", so I went in with relatively low expectations... but that red-headed orphan completely pulled me in, and I felt the charm of the characters and the island and Anne's imagination every page from cover to cover. There is very little "story" to speak of -- mostly it's a collection of vignettes across 5 years of Anne's childhood and adolescence, with not much connecting them and sometimes whole seasons in between. But very little of it is told from her point-of-view, and the narration is quite matter-of-fact when it comes to the characters' thoughts and feelings, which gives the story a bit of a fly-on-the-wall quality. It makes reading about Anne's escapades feel very much like you're there fondly watching her grow up, from a small distance, and so are just as amused and mystified by her idiosyncracies as the other adults in the story.

Gradings:4
1
favorite_border
on May 2, 2025
on April 24, 2025
on April 7, 2025
on April 7, 2025